At one point in my career, I had a dashboard with roughly 50 metrics. They spanned several wall-mounted monitors. Big numbers. Reds and greens. It was glorious. I wanted visibility into everything. I thought that was part of doing the job well.
Revenue. Pipeline. Tickets. Delivery. KPIs galore!
We measured almost everything the company produced.
There was one thing I never measured.
The quality of my judgment.
Looking back over 17 years as a CEO, I think that mattered more than almost every number on the dashboard.
I had poor judgement in hiring employees. Who I thought would be loyal rockstars, later encouraged mutiny and tried to sink the ship. Who I thought wouldn’t last, grew into seasoned professionals I admire to this day.
I took the company in a different direction entirely.
I made decisions on my own, no one I could confide in and no one who could point out my blind spots, my biases, my belief systems. It cost me more than just money.
A company can recover from a bad quarter. A sustained period of poor CEO judgment is much harder to survive.
Hire the wrong executive and leave them in place for years. Stay in a market after the evidence has changed. Make an acquisition for reasons you cannot admit to yourself. Avoid confronting a co-founder. Raise too much money, too little money, or money from the wrong people. You hold onto something because it worked five years ago and has become part of how you see yourself.
A few key decisions can determine the next several years of a company.
Yet most CEOs don’t examine the quality of their faculties producing those decisions.
I think they should. Well, it’s how I’ve been measuring my own decisions for about a decade now.
I call it Return on Judgment.
The CEO’s scarce resource
Turns out, the phrase “return on judgment” has been used before. I found a 2010 business strategy article about risk management that used the phrase to describe the value organizations get when experienced people have the information and accountability needed to exercise judgment.
My definition is narrower.
Return on Judgment, or ROJ, is the return generated by the decisions that genuinely require the CEO’s judgment relative to the attention those decisions consume.
You can think about it roughly as:
ROJ = consequential value created or protected / CEO attention spent on decisions only the CEO should make
This is not an accounting formula. I would never put ROJ next to gross margin and pretend we could calculate it to two decimal places.
Its value comes from forcing a different question.
What am I doing with the judgment the company is paying me to exercise?
That question gets surprisingly uncomfortable.
McKinsey surveyed executives about organizational decision-making and found that more than half spent over 30 percent of their working time making decisions. Among C-suite executives, 14 percent said decision-making consumed more than 70 percent of their time. Yet 57 percent of C-suite respondents said most of that decision-making time was used ineffectively.
That is an extraordinary amount of executive capacity going into an activity most companies barely examine.
We examine the results in due time.
We rarely examine the judgment that produced them.
Decisions that matter
A CEO should make relatively few decisions, I say now from my pulpit.
That took me a long time to learn.
My case history showed the opposite. It showed that decisions were moving upward because the company had learned that I would make them.
Some genuinely belonged with me. Many, many, many, many, many did not.
That distinction matters for ROJ.
Every decision made carries two costs.
The obvious cost is time.
The larger cost is what happens to the organization when people learn that difficult decisions eventually move toward the CEO.
They stop developing judgment of their own. Put even simpler, they stop developing.
McKinsey separates senior-level decisions into categories. Some are genuine “big bets,” such as acquisitions or major capital investments. Others cut across the company, such as pricing or resource allocation. Many operational decisions belong with the people closest to the information. Treating all of them the same produces slower organizations and overloaded executives.
A CEO with high ROJ gets very selective.
Which market are we entering?
Who belongs on the executive team?
Where should the next dollar of capital go?
What risk could threaten the company?
What truth are we refusing to face?
Those decisions deserve CEO attention.
The look and feel of the website does not.
Neither do hundreds of choices made by capable executives who have learned to wait for the CEO.
My 50-metric dashboard gave me an enormous amount of information. It also encouraged me to stay involved in an enormous number of things.
Eventually I reduced it to three metrics and created ways for the team to make decisions without me.
That was a better use of my judgment.
Good judgment is more than intelligence
This is where ROJ becomes personal.
CEOs tend to think of judgment as a cognitive skill.
Get good information. Understand the alternatives. Think through the consequences. Make the call.
All of that matters.
It leaves out the person making the decision.
One of the most expensive decisions of my career involved my co-founder. My judgment had been influenced by conflict avoidance.
That experience changed the way I think about CEO decision-making. The spreadsheet is only one participant in the decision.
Fear is there too.
So is ego.
The relationship with control can be sitting at the table. The need to be liked can have a vote. An identity developed during youth ago can quietly determine what you are willing to see today.
These things rarely speak up during decision making time. But they are the lens from which we see the world.
“We should give him another quarter.”
“I need more data.”
“Nobody else can handle this yet.”
“This customer is too important.”
“We have already invested too much to stop now.”
Sometimes those statements are true.
Sometimes they are stories protecting the CEO from something more difficult.
That distinction heavily skews judgment.
Your internal condition appears in your decisions
I learned another version of this through burnout.
During periods when I was burned out, my decisions changed – for the worse.
I became narrower and more reactive. Complex conversations felt heavier, so I delayed some of them. My patience decreased. My relationship with risk became inconsistent.
The company still had dashboards. I still had experience. My IQ had presumably remained where I left it.
The person interpreting the information had changed.
Research from INSEAD on high-stakes CEO decisions points to this problem. In one study involving 111 CEOs, leaders described psychological pressure, personal biases, competing stakeholder interests, and unreliable information as recurring difficulties in major decisions. More than 60 percent cited unpredictable markets and poor data as complications.
A CEO never makes a decision from some perfectly neutral place.
We bring our whole selves into the room.
This is why I have become increasingly interested in the relationship between self-awareness and judgment.
If I am afraid of conflict, some options become harder for me to see.
If my identity depends on being indispensable, delegation becomes emotionally expensive.
If my self-worth comes from winning, walking away from a losing investment becomes harder.
If I am exhausted, lonely, angry, or desperate for an outcome, the facts may remain identical while my interpretation changes.
The most sophisticated financial model in the world cannot correct for a CEO who does not understand what is happening inside himself.
A good outcome can come from a bad decision
ROJ has another problem.
Luck.
Suppose you make an irresponsible acquisition and the market unexpectedly explodes upward. The acquisition becomes a financial success.
Was it good judgment?
Suppose you make a thoughtful investment based on strong information and a completely unforeseeable event destroys the market.
Was it bad judgment?
We have a strong tendency to judge decisions by their outcomes.
Researchers call this outcome bias. Experiments going back decades have repeatedly found that people rate identical decisions more favorably when the eventual outcome is good. A large preregistered replication published in 2023 found the effect again, even among people who explicitly said outcomes should not influence their assessment.
That creates a serious problem for CEOs.
Success can teach you the wrong lesson.
A lucky outcome can reinforce bad judgment. An unlucky outcome can cause you to abandon a sound way of thinking.
So ROJ has to be evaluated before you know how the story ends.
That requires keeping a record.
The ROJ ledger
I keep a judgment ledger alongside the financial dashboards.
Only consequential CEO decisions go into it.
Before making one, I write down what I believe.
What decision am I actually making?
Why does this decision belong with me?
What facts do I have?
What assumptions am I making?
What would have to be true for this decision to work?
What evidence would change my mind?
What am I feeling that could be affecting what I see?
What outcome do I expect, and how confident am I?
Then I leave it alone.
Three months later, six months later, or two years later, depending on the decision, I come back to it.
I compare what I believed then with what I know now.
Some decisions produce good outcomes because the judgment was sound.
Some work because I got lucky.
Some fail even though the reasoning was solid.
And some expose a recurring pattern in me.
Those last ones are the most interesting.
Maybe I consistently wait too long.
Maybe I overestimate things I am personally excited about.
Maybe I become too conservative after a loss.
Maybe I seek more information whenever the real difficulty is emotional.
After enough decisions, a picture begins to form.
That picture is my ROJ.
I learn where my judgment is strong, where I repeatedly distort reality, and which decisions should never have reached me in the first place.
Improving ROJ
The CEO Genome research examined thousands of executives and found that people described as decisive were far more likely to become high-performing CEOs. The research also found that poor decisiveness was overwhelmingly associated with deciding too slowly rather than acting too quickly. (What Sets Successful CEOs Apart)
Speed matters.
I would add another dimension.
A fast decision made for an unconscious reason can simply get you to the wrong place sooner.
Improving ROJ requires better information, strong debate, and people around you who are willing to disagree. It also requires the capacity to notice when the biggest source of distortion is sitting in your chair.
That part took me years to understand.
I entered therapy at 30 because my anxiety had become difficult to live with. At the time, I thought other people and circumstances were creating most of my problems. Over time, I’ve come to see how much of leadership comes from places I rarely discussed in executive meetings.
Identity.
Fear.
Old ideas about worth.
Our relationship with power and approval.
They show up in who gets hired, who gets fired, what risks get taken, which conversations get postponed, and how long the CEO remains attached to a decision whose time has passed.
They become economics.
The metric behind metrics
Boards measure CEOs largely through outcomes.
Those measures should exist. They tell us what happened. They cannot fully tell us why it happened.
ROJ asks a different question.
What quality of judgment is producing these outcomes?
Over a long enough period, that may be the most important CEO metric there is.
Because almost every number eventually traces back to a series of human decisions.
Which people did we trust?
Which risks did we take?
Which market did we enter?
What did we stop doing?
What did we refuse to admit?
What did the CEO see before everyone else?
What was the CEO unable to see because of something within himself?
I no longer look at multi-colored dashboards. I know what my most important metric is. Aligned with my values, I like the direction it has been taking me.
Return on Judgment: Questions CEOs Ask Me
What is Return on Judgment (ROJ)?
Return on Judgment is the return generated by the decisions that genuinely require the CEO’s judgment, relative to the attention those decisions consume. I use it as a question more than a formula. What am I doing with the judgment the company is paying me to exercise?
What is the most important metric for a CEO?
After 17 years as a CEO, I think it is the quality of your own judgment. Revenue, margin, and pipeline tell you what happened. Almost every one of those numbers traces back to a few human decisions about people, capital, markets, and risk. The judgment producing those decisions is the metric behind the metrics.
Which decisions should a CEO actually make?
Relatively few. Which market to enter, who belongs on the executive team, where the next dollar of capital goes, what risk could threaten the company, and what truth the company is refusing to face. Most other decisions belong with the people closest to the information. When they keep moving up to you, your team stops developing judgment of its own.
How do you judge a decision when luck affects the outcome?
You evaluate it before you know how the story ends. Outcome bias leads us to rate the same decision more favorably when the result is good, so a lucky win can reinforce bad judgment. I keep a judgment ledger. Before a consequential decision I write down my facts, assumptions, feelings, and expected outcome, then compare that record with what I know later.
How can a CEO improve their judgment?
Better information, strong debate, and people willing to disagree all help. The harder part is noticing when the biggest source of distortion is sitting in your chair. Fear, ego, conflict avoidance, burnout, and old ideas about worth shape what you are able to see. Self-awareness is what lets you catch them before they become economics.
